I would have to say that the MS Sidewinder gamepad for the PC is the most
comfortable to me. It has a very soft D-Pad, 6 buttons up front and the 2
trigger buttons. I would rather play the computer version of a game with
the sidewinder than any console game. As for consoles, I don't think any of
them are that great. The X-Box controller is pretty heavy, the DC
controller has the trigger buttons at strange locations (perhaps my fingers
are just too long), and the PS controllers leave rough spots on my hand from
playing. Aren't we entitled to a well designed and comfortable
controller???
Mike